House Favorites
Weekly Specials
Margherita Pizza Sub
A 12” pizza sub with our garlic marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil
$10.99
Nashville Chicken Stuffed Pepper Mac-n-Cheese
Our homemade Nashville chicken stuffed peppers chopped in a home-style mac-n-cheese topped with dill pickle chips, and a hot honey drizzle.
$12.99
Tex-Mex Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Tex-Mex breaded crispy chicken topped with homemade pico de gallo, queso, crushed fritos, and a homemade chipotle ranch dressing on a toasted rustic hoagie roll. Served with tequila lime seasoned fresh cut french fries.
$14.99
"The Bull" Melt
Chopped ribeye, our homemade stuffed hungarian pepper, and deep-fried mozzarella sticks between two pieces of garlic texas toast. Served with deli style potato chips and a pickle.
$15.99
Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$8.99
Extra Bleu Cheese
$1.50
Specialty Pizza
White Pizza
Traditional tomato and onion or your choice of up to 4 veggies with our homemade white sauce.
$21.49
Poor Man's Lasagna Pizza
Chopped meatballs, fresh ricotta, and mozzarella, on our garlic marinara sauce.
$21.49
Honey Sriracha Pizza
Choice of pepperoni or sausage on our garlic marinara sauce with a honey sriracha drizzle, and a fresh basil finish.
$21.49
Chicken Finger Pizza
Choice of fingers, with bleu cheese sauce.
$21.49
Meat Lovers Pizza
With pepperoni, Italian sausage, bacon, and ham.
$23.99
Stuffed Hungarian Pepper Pizza
With homemade stuffed Hungarian peppers and a garlic butter sauce.
$23.99
Hawaiian Pizza
Chopped pineapple and ham, with our semi-sweet sauce, topped with mozzarella and provolone cheeses.
$21.49
Pizza Of The Month
Check our website for this month's pie.
$23.99
Philly Steak Pizza
With green peppers, mushrooms, onions plus a three-cheese blend on our homemade white sauce.
$25.99
Philly Chicken Pizza
With green peppers, mushrooms, onions plus a three-cheese blend on our homemade white sauce.
$25.99
Mac-n-Cheese Pizza of the Month
check our website for this month's pie (*some prices may vary)
$25.99
The Works Pizza
With pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, onions, banana peppers, black olives and green olives.
$25.99
Original Mac-n-Cheese Pizza
A five-cheese mac-n-cheese pizza on a garlic buttered crust
$23.99
Extra Bleu Cheese
$1.50
Pizza by the Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice
Cheese and cheese pepperoni available daily (while supplies last)
$3.49
Slice Of The Day
$4.89
Two Pizza Slices & Drink Special
Available while supplies last. We do not sell "make your own slices" to order
$9.69
Everyday Combos & Specials
Any 8" Sub, Side & Drink Special
$8.49
Small Pizza (1) Topping, 10 Wings
$31.99
Small Pizza (1) Topping, Single Finger or (12) Boneless Wings
Small Pizza with your choice of chicken fingers and fresh cut french fries or boneless wings
$30.99
Large Pizza (1) Topping, 20 Wings
$52.99
Large Pizza (1) Topping, Double Fingers or (24) Boneless Wings
Large (1) Topping Pizza, with your choice of a double order of chicken fingers or (24) boneless wings.
$50.99
Half Tray (1) Topping, 30 Wings
$72.99
Full Tray (1) Topping, 50 Wings
$105.99
Appetizers & Sides
Fresh Cut French Fries
Cut fresh in house, then deep fried to perfection!
$4.49
Deli Style Potato Chips
Your choice of original or cajun style.
$4.49
Onion Rings
thick cut beer-battered onion rings.
$7.99
Mozzarella Sticks
Deep-fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside.
$7.99
Pizza Logs
$8.99
Taco Logs
Served with sour cream.
$8.99
Homemade Mac & Cheese
Made to order!
$9.99
Bread Sticks
Served with our semi-sweet sauce.
$9.99
Stuffed Hungarian Peppers
An order of three with a homemade sausage stuffing recipe. Baked and topped with mozzarella cheese.
$13.99
Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Peppers
An order of three filled with a homemade buffalo chicken mix. Baked and topped with mozzarella cheese.
$13.99
Potato Skins
Four homemade potato skins topped with melted cheddar cheese and bacon crumbles. Served with side of sour cream.
$9.99
Jalapeno Poppers
Five homemade jalapeño poppers stuffed with cream cheese, cheddar and bacon. Served with side of sour cream.
$7.99
Sweet Potato Fries
Fresh cut sweet potato fries tossed with honey and butter.
$7.99
Extra Bleu Cheese
2 oz cup of our homemade bleu cheese
$1.50
Ranch
2 oz cup of ranch
$1.00
Nashville Chicken Stuffed Peppers
homemade stuffed hungarian peppers filled with a nashville chicken blend, topped with melted cheddar and mozzarella cheese, dill pickle chips and a hot honey drizzle.
$13.99
Fried Mushrooms
deep fried mushrooms served with our homemade bleu cheese.
$7.99
Salads
Greek Salad
A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, black and green olives, feta cheese and pepperoncini; served with pita.
$9.99
Antipasto Salad
A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, ham, capicola, salami, pepperoni and mozzarella cheese.
$10.99
Caesar Salad
A bed of romaine lettuce topped with croutons and shredded parmesan cheese.
$8.49
Julienne Salad
A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, ham, turkey and mozzarella cheese.
$10.99
Buffalo Chicken Salad
A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers and mozzarella cheese with your choice of fingers.
$10.99
Chef Salad
A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers and mozzarella cheese.
$8.49
Wings, Fingers & Boneless Wings
Boneless Wings
Served with bleu cheese, carrots and celery.
$14.99
Fingers
Served with fresh-cut fries, bleu cheese, carrots and celery.
$15.99
Wings
Sauce Options: Plain, Hot, Medium, Mild and BBQ Specialty Options: ($1.00 upcharge) Cajun, Garlic Parm, Buffalo Garlic, Cajun BBQ, Horseradish Mustard, Mum's Sauce, Inferno*, Honey BBQ, Honey Hot, Honey Garlic, Honey Sriracha, Maple Bacon BBQ, Jamaican Jerk, Cajun Honey Butter BBQ, Honey Mustard, Lemon Pepper, Spicy Lemon Pepper, Apple Cider Whiskey BBQ, Italian Herbs, Old Bay, Spicy Peach, Spicy Pickle, Tennessee Smoke, Tequila Lime Served with bleu cheese, carrots and celery.
$16.99
Extra Bleu Cheese
$1.50
Calzones
Cheese Calzone
With ricotta and mozzarella.
$9.99
Cheese & One Topping Calzone
choice of one topping
$11.99
Stuffed Hungarian Pepper Calzone
With our homemade stuffed peppers.
$13.99
Chicken Finger Calzone
Choice of sauce, served with bleu cheese.
$13.99
Calzone Of The Month
Check out our website for this month’s calzone!
$14.99
Cold Subs
Ham and Cheese
Made with thin sliced Sahlen's ham
$8.49
Turkey and Cheese
Made with thin sliced Michigan turkey breast.
$9.49
Assorted Sub
Classic Italian cold cut sub with Sahlen's ham, hot capicola and salami.
$9.49
Roast Beef
Slow-cooked roast beef, thin sliced. Ask to add homemade horseradish-mayo to this!
$9.99
Hot Subs
Sausage and Cheese
Made with locally produced Italian sausage patties.
$10.49
Steak and Cheese
Made with chopped ribeye steak.
$10.49
Cheeseburger Sub
Made with fresh 4-oz beef patties, topped with yellow-american cheese.
$10.49
Grilled Chicken Sub
Made with fresh 6-oz diced double-lobe chicken breast
$10.49
BLT
Thick cut crispy bacon with lettuce, tomato and swiss-american cheese.
$10.49
Specialty Subs
Royal
Your choice of Italian sausage, ribeye steak or grilled chicken with grilled hot capicola.
$10.99
Philly
Your choice of ribeye steak, grilled chicken breast or Italian sausage with sauteed green peppers, mushrooms, and onions; topped with melted yellow-american cheese.
$11.99
Chicken Finger
Made with your choice of fingers, sauces listed under "Wings, Fingers and Boneless Wings"
$11.99
Stinger
A Buffalo staple! Made with ribeye steak, chicken fingers sauced your way and melted provolone cheese.
$12.49
Sausage Parm
Grilled Italian sausage topped with your choice of sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese. Ask to load it up!
$10.49
Pizza Sub
Your favorite pizza in sub form!
$9.49
Chicken Parm
Chicken fingers topped with your choice of sauce and topped with melted mozzarella.
$10.49
Meatball Parm
Loaded with 1-oz meatballs topped with your choice of sauce, and melted mozzarella.
$10.49
Stuffed Pepper Parm
Our homemade sausage stuffed hungarian peppers topped with your choice of sauce and melted mozzarella.
$10.99
Bologna and Onion
Diced fried bologna with sauteed onions and melted yellow american cheese.
$9.49
Seafood Friday Dinners
Beer Battered Fish Fry
An 8-10 oz homemade beer-battered cod fish fry. Served with fresh cut french-fries, homemade coleslaw, tartar sauce, a lemon wedge and garlic toast.
$16.99
Shrimp Basket
10 jumbo deep fried tail-on shrimp served with our fresh cut french-fries, homemade coleslaw, cocktail sauce, a lemon wedge and garlic toast.
$14.99
Beverages
Pop
12-oz cans or 2-Liters in Pepsi products.
$2.07
20-Oz Aquafina
$2.07
Desserts
Apple Pie Logs
Served with caramel sauce.
$8.99
Cinnamon Sticks
Topped with vanilla icing.
$6.99
Fatman's Pizza
Looking for something good to eat? Try the best pizzas in Tonawanda. Fatman's Pizza remains one of the most popular in Tonawanda thanks to its fresh offerings and classic pizzas. Give their menu a try and see what all the fuss is about. If you're feeling hungry, don't hesitate. Enjoy the top dishes Tonawanda has to offer. This restaurant is known for Cheese Pizza. Try it for yourself and see what the fuss is about. It's not just pizza. Try fresh cut french fries for a delicious addition to your meal. Even the biggest appetite can be satisfied here. Fatman's Pizza has been a Slice partner for 6 years. This local business is a feature of the community it serves. Curbside pickup makes takeout easy. All you have to do is place an order and show up. You can't beat that for convenience! Pay by credit card to make the checkout process easier. Follow Fatman's Pizza on social media to keep up with the latest news.
Full Hours